Skip to content

Limitations

Morrigan is a statistical model of the giant-impact phase, not an N-body integrator. Its approximations are inherited from Kimura et al. (2025)1 and from the choices of this implementation; the ones a user should hold in mind are listed here.

Dynamical approximations

  • Semi-analytic timing. Instability times come from the Petit et al. (2020)3 crossing-time fit and calibrated interaction timescales, not from direct integration. Individual system histories are statistical realisations; only ensemble statistics are meaningful for comparison with N-body results.
  • Perfect merging. Collisions always merge the pair. There is no fragmentation, no hit-and-run channel, and no debris, so a body only ever grows: the merged mass is the exact sum of the two, and mass leaves a system only when a body is ejected or falls into the star.
  • Single impact angle. One configured impact angle applies to every collision of a run; the model does not draw a distribution of impact geometries.
  • Linear secular theory. Eccentricities between events follow the Laplace-Lagrange solution, which is linear in eccentricity and excludes inclination; the model is two-dimensional, and radially overlapping neighbours are simply decoupled from the secular solution.
  • No dissipation. There is no gas drag, no tidal damping, and no dynamical friction from a planetesimal population; excitation is removed only by mergers, ejections2 (whether through an eccentricity driven past unity or a scattering that leaves an orbit hyperbolic), and the star-infall cutoff.

Atmospheres

  • The model carries no atmosphere. Bodies are bare: a mass is a bulk mass, a radius follows from it at the configured bulk density, and no envelope is tracked or shed. A giant impact erodes a real atmosphere, and that erosion is applied downstream by the consumer rather than here; in a coupled PROTEUS run it comes from zephyrus.collision.mass_loss, evaluated from the impact geometry each record carries. The scaling law itself is Kegerreis et al. (2020)4.
  • Bodies are bulk objects in the dynamics too: radii do not distinguish a rocky core from an envelope, so a body with a heavy envelope is represented by its bulk mass and radius alone.

Impact melt

  • A bulk melt fraction only. The melt fraction is the mantle-averaged energy criterion of Nakajima et al. (2021)5, a mean energy gain over \(E_M\), a value the authors call not well constrained; the shape of the melt pool and the pressure at its base (their eqs. 9 to 11 and 13 in arXiv:2004.04269v2) are not computed. The fit is least certain for grazing impacts: the relative 1-sigma of the internal energy fit grows from 0.06 head-on to 0.63 at 90Β°. The merging coefficients of Nakajima et al. come from impacts at the escape speed only, so a merger faster than that is outside their data even when it is below the critical speed and inside the flagged range.
  • Merging coefficients for every merger. A collision faster than the Genda et al. (2012)6 critical speed would be a hit-and-run in the SPH runs; Morrigan merges it and evaluates the merging fit, flagged by above_v_cr. Outside the campaign's mass, mass-ratio and speed range the fit is extrapolated and melt_in_range is false; the merging fit itself comes from the runs at \(v_\mathrm{imp} = v_\mathrm{esc}\).

Numerical conventions

  • The gravitational constant is carried at three significant figures (6.67e-11), the au as 1.5e11 m (0.27 % from the defined value), and the year as 365 days; results agree with CODATA-constant implementations only to the corresponding relative level, which matters when cross-checking against other codes.
  • All Monte Carlo draws share numpy's global random state, seeded per system. Library code must never reseed mid-run; a hidden reseed would silently correlate ensemble members.
  • Ejections remove the body excited past unity eccentricity; its unbound orbit is not followed, and the survivor's orbit conserves the pair's orbital energy at the moment of the event.
  • The excitation applied to a pair before a collision is drawn without an upper bound, and so is the fallback taken when no draw satisfies the overlap condition. A body can therefore enter the collision branch already past unity eccentricity, which the ejection branch treats as grounds for removing it: the two branches disagree about what an unbound orbit means. Such a body is removed on the same step by the perihelion cut, so it does not survive to be reported, and the impact histories run_system returns are unaffected. A caller reading the raw merger list rather than the returned histories can see an eccentricity at or above one and should check for it.

References


  1. Kimura, T., Hoshino, H., Kokubo, E., Matsumoto, Y. & Ikoma, M., Semi-analytical Model for the Dynamical Evolution of Planetary Systems via Giant Impacts, The Astrophysical Journal, 989, 109, 2025. ↩

  2. Kimura, T., Kokubo, E., Matsumoto, Y., Mordasini, C. & Ikoma, M., Semi-analytical model for the dynamical evolution of planetary system II: Application to systems formed by a planet formation model, arXiv:2507.03906, 2025. ↩

  3. Petit, A.C., Pichierri, G., Davies, M.B. & Johansen, A., The path to instability in compact multi-planetary systems, Astronomy & Astrophysics, 641, A176, 2020. ↩

  4. Kegerreis, J.A., Eke, V.R., Catling, D.C., Massey, R.J., Teodoro, L.F.A. & Zahnle, K.J., Atmospheric Erosion by Giant Impacts onto Terrestrial Planets: A Scaling Law for any Speed, Angle, Mass, and Density, The Astrophysical Journal Letters, 901, L31, 2020. ↩

  5. Nakajima, M., Golabek, G.J., WΓΌnnemann, K., Rubie, D.C., Burger, C., Melosh, H.J., Jacobson, S.A., Manske, L. & Hull, S.D., Scaling laws for the geometry of an impact-induced magma ocean, Earth and Planetary Science Letters, 568, 116983, 2021. ↩

  6. Genda, H., Kokubo, E. & Ida, S., Merging criteria for giant impacts of protoplanets, The Astrophysical Journal, 744, 137, 2012. ↩